Amazing 350-Calorie Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches

There is honestly nothing better on a hot summer evening than biting into a perfectly assembled chocolate chip ice cream sandwich. It just tastes like being a kid again, right? But sometimes, when the craving hits, I don’t have time to bake two dozen cookies from scratch just to hide creamy ice cream between them. That’s where my absolute favorite shortcut comes into play! Trust me when I say that making perfect Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House! I’ve been assembling these treats for years, especially for last-minute pool parties. It’s fast, it feels homemade, and because we start with that famous dough, the cookies are unbeatable. If you want the best chocolate chip cookie to ever hold ice cream, you definitely need to check out my favorite bake sale cookies recipe for inspiration—though we’re sticking to the refrigerated dough today for speed!

Why You Will Love These Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!

I promise you that this recipe is peak home baking efficiency. Why wouldn’t you fall in love with giant, perfect ice cream sandwiches?

• You get the classic, chewy flavor because Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!
• The prep time is practically zero since the dough is ready to go.
• They come together fast, which means less time waiting and more time eating.
• Check out my favorite quick dessert assembly ideas if you need more inspiration like this!

Ingredients Needed for Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!

The best part about this recipe? Minimal stops at the grocery store. We are keeping this super simple because using that refrigerated dough is the magic ticket. You just need the dough and your ice cream!

• 1 package (16.5 ounces) Nestle Toll House refrigerated cookie dough. Yes, the kind that chills in the fridge!
• 1.5 quarts vanilla ice cream, but here’s a little secret—make sure it’s slightly softened before you start scooping.

Seriously, that’s it! If you want to see more ways to upgrade your Toll House game, take a peek at my guide on using Toll House cookies in creative ways.

Baking the Perfect Toll House Cookies for Your Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!

Okay, this is where we put in just a tiny bit of work, but it pays off hugely when you bite into that sandwich later. First, you need to preheat your oven exactly how the package tells you to for the Nestle dough. Line those baking sheets with parchment paper; trust me, cleanup will be a dream later! Drop your dough onto the sheets, but here’s my pro-tip: try to make them a little flatter than you usually would. They need to be a good size for sandwiching, so don’t pile them too high. When they bake, watch those edges! You want them beautifully golden brown, not pale. That golden edge means they’ll have enough structure when they cool down to hold all that glorious ice cream we’re about to add. If you want some more baking wisdom, check out my guide on using Toll House cookies in creative ways.

Cooling the Cookies Completely

This step is non-negotiable, friend. Let them hang out on the hot pan for about five minutes so they firm up a bit, but then they have to move to a wire rack. They must be completely, perfectly cool to the touch before we even think about scooping ice cream. If they are even slightly warm, you’ll end up with soup!

Simple Frozen Treats Assembly: Making Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!

Now for the fun part—bringing this easy dessert assembly together! You’ve got your perfectly cooled cookies, and you’ve got your slightly softened ice cream. Grab your cookies and place them with the flat side facing up. Take a generous scoop—about a third of a cup is what I use—of that softened vanilla ice cream and glob it right onto one cookie. This is where working fast matters! Gently place the second cookie on top, flat side down, and start pressing lightly. You don’t want to squish everything out the sides, just enough pressure so that the ice cream spreads out evenly to meet the edges. If you need some extra ideas for your simple frozen treats assembly, just remember this one rule: match your cookie sizes as closely as possible!

Optional Edge Rolling for Your Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipe

This is purely for looks, but who doesn’t love extra chocolate chips? If you want that classic, professional look, now is the time to roll those exposed ice cream edges. Have a shallow plate ready with some mini chocolate chips or festive sprinkles. Just tilt the sandwich sideways and gently press that gooey edge into whatever topping you choose. It sticks instantly! This extra step really makes your Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House! look like they came from the fanciest ice cream parlor.

Tips for Success in Your Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipe

I have a few tricks up my sleeve to make sure your hands don’t get too sticky while making these treats. The number one rule is speed. Work in small batches with the ice cream because the moment it gets warm, it starts to run everywhere! Don’t try to assemble all ten sandwiches at once if you aren’t used to it; just do two or three, freeze them quick, and then go back for more.

Also, take a second to match up your cookies before you dive in. Grab two cookies that look like they were cut from the same mold—a slightly bigger one on the bottom and a slightly smaller one on top just leads to ice cream leakage! For more pointers on achieving perfection, I always refer back to my best tips on the best way to make ice cream sandwiches at home.

Make-Ahead Ice Cream Sandwich Guide: Freezing Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House!

We finished assembling, and now we need to rush these babies into the deep freeze! Pop the finished sandwiches onto a tray lined with parchment paper. They need to freeze solid, which means giving them at least two hours in the freezer without being bothered. Once they are rock hard, you want to wrap them individually. Seriously, plastic wrap works best to keep the air out and prevent freezer burn on your beautiful cookies. This is how you make sure your Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House! stay perfect for when the next craving strikes! For more steps on making these ahead, check out my full make-ahead ice cream sandwich guide.

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions for Using Toll House Cookies for Ice Cream Sandwiches

I used vanilla ice cream here because it lets those amazing Toll House cookies shine through, but please don’t feel limited! If you’re feeling adventurous, strawberry or even coffee ice cream makes a gorgeous combination. Just remember to let whatever flavor you pick soften up just a little bit before assembly, as directed.

Now, about cookie size: this recipe usually yields about ten perfect sandwiches. If your cookies end up a little bigger or smaller than you expected, just adjust the amount of ice cream you scoop. Bigger cookies get a little more filling; smaller ones get a little less. If you want to see what other cookies pair well with ice cream, I have a whole post on the perfect cookie pairing for ice cream!

FAQ about Making Easy Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches

I’ve gathered up the most common questions I get when people try this simple frozen treats assembly for the first time. It all comes down to making sure you get that perfect, classic texture!

Can I skip baking the cookies and use them frozen?

Oh goodness, no! You really need to bake these cookies first. If you try to sandwich ice cream between raw cookie dough, you end up with a gooey, sad mess that doesn’t set up right. Baking them gives us that chewy edge and structure we desperately need to hold everything together. It’s a key step in our homemade ice cream sandwiches recipe.

How long do these Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House! last in the freezer?

If you wrap them tightly—I mean *tightly*—in plastic wrap like I showed you, they honestly last great for a couple of weeks. After about three weeks, the cookie texture starts to change a tiny bit. But honestly, these Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches are so easy with Nestle Toll House! that they usually disappear within the first 48 hours around my house!

For more fun assembly ideas that kids love, take a look at my guide on kid friendly ice cream sandwich making.

Serving Suggestions for Your Toll House Cookie Ice Cream Dessert

While these are fantastic straight from the freezer after they’ve set up for a couple of hours, presentation always helps! If you’re feeling fancy, try drizzling just a little caramel sauce over the top right before serving. Or, if you’re making these in the winter instead of the summer, grab a mug of strong coffee to sip alongside your sandwich. It’s a perfect adult indulgence, courtesy of those wonderful quick dessert assembly ideas!

Print